I had this too. I figured it was because the one I'd selected was the lowest, so the "also remove the lowest" bit didn't apply. I do see that there's another thread saying we're reverting, though.

From what I can gather last month's scores were much higher than usual, which I'm guessing is down to the remove 2 feature (1 and 2 - your good self - were both 6 reviews of 8 I believe).

I didn't bother saying anything after my remove experience because I was lucky enough to get into the Top10 last month, hot on your heels, but I see this is an extract of yours that's waiting to get in, so I'll wade in to back you up - I'm all for going back to 1 but the removes probably ought to do what they say they're going to (informed choices and all), so I'll join the give Bill back his review campaign.

Today we are back to remove one in eight remove reviews.

Hi BillMc, I can readd this review, you did correctly remove the lowest one, let me know.

Hi LibbyAst, for Treespeaker currently you have received 31 Assignment reviews overall, including the 3 removed already, so you need one more to remove a review. The Dragon Box has 24 reviews with 3 removed already.

Best

Ted

Hi Katie

Upon going back to the system of remove one in eight today, the system ensures that members can remove only 1 review every 8 and multiples of 8 thereafter. At 24 the maximum amount of reviews that the system will now allow to remove is 3 until another 8 reviews are received. Any previous emails may have originated from the 2 in 8 system which was trialed last month. I hope this explains how the system process works.

Ted

Hi Ted. Thanks for the quick answer. Yes, please readd the deleted review as long as I am not somehow losing my delete review option that I get for having 8. If my delete is gone forever then, please leave it deleted. Does that make sense?

Also, I can't seem to find my book The Second Siege on the Top Ten list. I know it dropped out of the actual Top Ten because there wasn't a credit assigned to it on July 2nd (though the message said end of the day and it really should have said beginning of the day, i.e. end of July 1 - but no big deal) but I can't seem to find it anywhere on the list. Not #22, not #71, etc. Where did it go? Am I somehow banned?

By the way, the feedback I have been getting is really helpful and I always feel a tad petty when we worry about deletes and rankings, etc. The best thing about your site is the constant feedback. Bravo Ted!

And Tommi, thanks for the backing. Hope you get the table at that restaurant you wanted.

Best, Bill

Hi Katie - if I read Ted right, I think you need to have 27 in order to remove another one now. I'm in the same boat If I'd known, I would have preferred just the one removal at 15 instead of 2, but never mind - at least everyone's in the same boat!
JR
Stop the sketch - it's too silly

NOt sure I understand this either.

I received yesterday a note that I am eligible for one remove, but there isna nae button there.

I had 8 reviews, removed 2 what brought the number down to 6.
Now, 8 reviews later, the overall count is 14, which equals a difference of eight reviews. No?

And it's very important to me to remove that darn vicious review.

Keep writing.

Me too, benkelly.

I didn't sent an email and I won't. But I must admit that I'm disappointed. Keep writing.